Testing and Interviewing Candidates – How to Hire Remotely

How To Hire

13 minute read

Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!

The testing and interviewing phase represents the crucial transition from application filtering to actual candidate evaluation. This is where you move beyond resumes and cover letters to witness how potential hires perform real work and interact in professional settings. It’s your opportunity to observe their skills in action, assess their communication style, and determine whether they’re truly capable of delivering the results your business needs.

Testing serves as the bridge between theoretical qualifications and practical application. Rather than relying solely on what candidates claim they can do, you’ll see concrete evidence of their abilities through carefully designed tasks that mirror the actual work they’ll perform if hired.

Section 1: The Foundation of Effective Testing

Why Testing Is Non-Negotiable

Testing represents a fundamental shift in your evaluation process. Instead of making hiring decisions based on interviews alone, you’re gathering tangible evidence of a candidate’s capabilities. This approach reveals not just what they can produce, but how they think, communicate, and approach problems under realistic conditions.

The testing phase provides insights that interviews simply cannot capture. You’ll observe their attention to detail, their ability to follow instructions, their problem-solving methodology, and their professional communication style. These observations become invaluable data points for making informed hiring decisions.

The Ethics of Compensation

Every test task should be compensated without exception. Requesting candidates to invest 2+ hours of their time without payment immediately establishes a precedent that you expect free work. This approach not only attracts candidates who may be desperate rather than skilled, but it also signals a lack of respect for professional time and expertise.

For different role types, establish reasonable compensation rates:

Virtual Assistant/Executive Assistant/Social Media/Customer Support roles: Up to $30 for the complete test
Developer positions: Up to $100 total for testing
Specialized roles: Adjust according to market rates and complexity

The investment in paid testing is minimal compared to the cost of a bad hire. Don’t compromise your candidate experience or your reputation for the sake of saving a small amount on testing costs.

Designing Meaningful Test Tasks

Your test tasks should accomplish multiple objectives simultaneously. They need to evaluate technical competency, demonstrate work quality, reveal communication patterns, and provide insight into the candidate’s professional approach. The most effective tests mirror actual work scenarios they’ll encounter in the role.

Structure your testing to require 1-2 hours of focused work. This timeframe is sufficient to demonstrate competency without creating an excessive burden for candidates. Always provide clear, detailed instructions unless you’re specifically testing their ability to seek clarification.

Section 2: Role-Specific Testing Strategies

Virtual Assistant Testing Framework

For Virtual Assistant roles, create test scenarios that encompass the breadth of tasks they’ll handle:

Research and Data Entry Tasks

Compile information about competitors or industry trends
Organize findings in a structured, easy-to-digest format
Demonstrate attention to accuracy and detail

Document Management Challenges

Format a complex document with specific styling requirements
Create spreadsheets with data analysis components
Perform proofreading tasks that require careful attention

Planning and Organization Exercises

Develop travel itineraries with multiple constraints
Create project timelines or task management systems
Demonstrate prioritization and organizational skills

Social Media candidates should demonstrate both creative and strategic thinking:

Content Creation Tasks

Develop a 30-day content calendar using your existing social presence as inspiration
Create three complete social media posts (copy and visual concepts) targeted to your specific audience
Demonstrate understanding of platform-specific best practices

Strategic Thinking Evaluation

Analyze your current social media performance and suggest improvements
Propose engagement strategies for different platforms
Show understanding of brand voice and audience preferences

Marketing Position Testing

Marketing roles require both analytical and creative capabilities:

Research and Analysis Projects

Conduct comprehensive competitor analysis
Identify market opportunities and threats
Present findings in actionable format

Strategic Planning Exercises

Develop 30, 60, or 90-day marketing plans
Create campaign concepts with clear objectives
Demonstrate understanding of marketing funnels and metrics

Developer Assessment Methods

Technical roles require hands-on coding challenges:

Practical Coding Tasks

Solve problems using your specific technology stack
Debug existing code samples
Build small features or components

System Understanding Tests

Demonstrate familiarity with your development environment
Show ability to work with existing codebases
Explain technical decision-making processes

Content Writer Evaluation

Writing roles need demonstration of both skill and understanding:

Sample Content Creation

Produce content that matches your brand voice
Write for your specific audience and industry
Demonstrate SEO understanding if relevant

Adaptation and Research Skills

Research unfamiliar topics and present clearly
Adapt writing style for different purposes
Show ability to follow brand guidelines

Project Manager Testing

Project management roles require organizational and leadership capabilities:

Planning and Organization Tasks

Create detailed project plans from provided information
Develop risk mitigation strategies
Demonstrate resource allocation skills

Communication and Presentation

Present project approaches clearly
Show ability to communicate with different stakeholders
Demonstrate conflict resolution thinking

Section 3: Test Task Implementation

Creating Effective Test Briefs

Your test task brief serves as the foundation for meaningful evaluation. Unless you’re specifically testing their ability to ask clarifying questions, provide comprehensive instructions that eliminate ambiguity. Include all necessary context, expected deliverables, time estimates, and success criteria.

Structure your brief to include:

Clear objective and expected outcomes
Specific deliverable format requirements
Timeline and submission instructions
Contact information for questions
Payment details and process
Any resources or materials they’ll need

Submission and Review Process

Standardize your submission process to make review efficient and fair. Request all materials in a single Google document when possible, or provide clear file naming conventions if multiple documents are required. This consistency helps you evaluate candidates fairly while streamlining your review process.

Create a systematic approach to evaluation by developing scoring criteria before reviewing submissions. Consider both the quality of work produced and the professionalism of the submission process. Pay attention to file permissions, communication clarity, and attention to detail in their submission.

Managing the Testing Timeline

Provide realistic timelines that account for candidates’ existing commitments. One week represents a reasonable timeframe for most test tasks, allowing candidates to produce quality work while maintaining their current responsibilities. Clearly communicate your review timeline and next steps to maintain positive candidate experience.

Section 4: Evaluation and Scoring Framework

Developing Consistent Evaluation Criteria

Create a standardized scoring system that evaluates both technical competency and professional approach. Your scoring framework should be consistent across all candidates while remaining flexible enough to account for different approaches to problem-solving.

Implement a simple but effective scoring system:

Excellent: Exceeds expectations, demonstrates exceptional skill
Good: Meets requirements, shows solid competency
Adequate: Acceptable quality, minor areas for improvement
Insufficient: Below requirements, significant concerns

Documentation and Tracking

Maintain detailed records of each candidate’s performance using your tracking spreadsheet. Add columns for:

Test task scores and detailed comments
Links to submitted materials
Specific observations about approach and quality
Areas of strength and concern
Overall recommendation for progression

This documentation becomes invaluable when making final decisions, especially when evaluating multiple strong candidates. It also provides a reference point for future hiring decisions and helps you refine your testing process over time.

Handling Non-Completion

Some candidates will not complete test tasks due to other opportunities, lack of interest, or inability to meet requirements. Don’t view this as entirely negative – you want candidates who are genuinely interested and willing to make the effort required for the role.

For candidates who appeared particularly strong in earlier stages, consider a brief follow-up to ensure they received your test brief and understand the requirements. Technical issues or miscommunication can sometimes prevent completion by otherwise qualified candidates.

Section 5: The Interview Process

Pre-Interview Preparation

Thorough preparation transforms interviews from stressful interrogations into productive conversations. Review all available information about each candidate, including their application materials, test task submissions, and any previous interactions. Use this information to develop specific questions that dig deeper into their experience and approach.

Your preparation should include:

Detailed review of their test task performance
Specific questions about their experience and background
Scenarios relevant to your business and role requirements
Notes about areas requiring clarification or deeper exploration

Creating the Right Environment

Successful interviews require the right environment and approach. Always conduct interviews via video call – seeing facial expressions, body language, and professional presentation provides crucial information that audio-only calls cannot deliver. If a candidate claims camera issues, reschedule rather than compromise this requirement.

Begin each interview with casual conversation to help candidates relax and show their personality. Nervous candidates cannot demonstrate their best qualities, so invest time in creating a comfortable atmosphere before diving into formal questions.

Interview Structure and Flow

Organize your interview into six distinct sections, each serving a specific purpose:

1. Breaking the Ice (5-10 minutes) Start with general conversation to help candidates relax and begin building rapport. Ask about their location, recent activities, or interests outside of work. This casual chat helps both parties feel more comfortable and provides insight into their personality and communication style.

2. Test Task Discussion (10-15 minutes) Review their test task performance directly with them. Ask about their approach, challenges they encountered, and how they felt about the final result. This discussion provides valuable insight into their problem-solving process and ability to receive feedback.

Use this opportunity to address any concerns or questions you had about their submission. Their response to feedback and ability to explain their decisions reveals important information about how they’ll handle similar situations in the actual role.

3. Scenario-Based Questions (15-20 minutes) Present realistic scenarios they’ll encounter in the role and ask how they would handle them. These questions should reflect actual challenges your business faces, such as:

Dealing with unclear requirements or conflicting priorities
Managing difficult customer interactions
Handling technical problems or system failures
Adapting to changing deadlines or project scope

Pay close attention to their thought process, not just their final answers. Look for evidence of logical thinking, appropriate questions, and realistic approaches to problem-solving.

4. Experience Deep Dive (10-15 minutes) Explore their background and previous roles with specific, probing questions. Don’t accept surface-level answers – dig deeper to understand what they actually accomplished and how they approached challenges.

Ask questions like:

“What were your three most significant achievements in that role?”
“What will you be remembered for in that position?”
“Describe the most challenging situation you faced and how you resolved it?”
“What would your previous manager say about your performance?”

Continue asking “why” and “how” questions to get beyond prepared responses and understand their actual experience and capabilities.

5. Understanding Their Motivations (10-15 minutes) Learn what drives them professionally and personally. Understanding their goals, preferences, and motivations helps you determine long-term fit and job satisfaction potential.

Key questions include:

“What type of work energizes you most?”
“How do you handle remote work challenges?”
“Where do you see your career heading in the next few years?”
“What’s most important to you in your next role?”

Their answers reveal whether your opportunity aligns with their goals and whether they’re likely to remain engaged and motivated in the position.

6. Their Questions and Next Steps (5-10 minutes) Always provide opportunity for candidate questions and clearly communicate your timeline and next steps. The questions they ask often reveal their level of interest, understanding of the role, and professional priorities.

Document their questions in your tracking system – they provide valuable insight into what matters most to them and how thoroughly they’ve considered the opportunity.

Advanced Interview Techniques

Behavioral Interviewing Use past behavior to predict future performance by asking candidates to describe specific situations they’ve encountered. Structure these questions using the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result) to get comprehensive answers.

Technical Deep Dives For technical roles, explore their expertise with specific examples and problem-solving scenarios. Ask them to walk through their approach to complex challenges they’ve faced.

Cultural Fit Assessment Evaluate alignment with your company values and working style through questions about their preferences, communication approach, and professional priorities.

Section 6: Candidate Evaluation and Decision Making

Comprehensive Assessment Framework

Effective evaluation requires systematic comparison of candidates across multiple dimensions. Create a standardized assessment that evaluates:

Technical Competency

Quality of test task completion
Depth of relevant experience
Problem-solving abilities
Industry knowledge and expertise

Communication and Professionalism

Clarity of written and verbal communication
Responsiveness and reliability
Professional presentation and attitude
Ability to ask appropriate questions

Cultural and Role Fit

Alignment with company values
Enthusiasm for the specific role
Long-term career goals compatibility
Working style preferences

Growth Potential

Eagerness to learn and develop
Adaptability to changing requirements
Leadership potential (if relevant)
Continuous improvement mindset

Managing Difficult Decisions

When multiple candidates perform well, making the final choice requires careful consideration of both immediate needs and long-term potential. Review all evaluation data systematically, considering:

Which candidate best fits your immediate business needs
Who demonstrates the strongest potential for growth
Which person aligns best with your company culture
Who shows the highest level of genuine interest in the role

Sometimes the decision comes down to intangible factors like enthusiasm, cultural fit, or communication style. These “soft” factors often determine long-term success more than pure technical ability.

When to Restart the Process

Recognize when your candidate pool isn’t strong enough to make a good hire. It’s better to restart your process than to compromise by selecting an inadequate candidate. Consider restarting when:

No candidates meet your minimum requirements
All candidates show significant red flags
You have concerns about long-term fit for all options
The testing process reveals gaps in your job requirements

Section 7: Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Testing Phase Mistakes

Insufficient Task Compensation Always pay for test work appropriately. Unpaid testing attracts desperate candidates rather than skilled professionals and establishes poor precedent for the working relationship.

Overly Complex or Lengthy Tests Keep tests focused and reasonable in scope. Excessive testing requirements discourage quality candidates and don’t provide proportionally better evaluation data.

Unclear Instructions Provide comprehensive briefings unless you’re specifically testing communication skills. Ambiguous instructions lead to inconsistent results that don’t reflect candidate capabilities.

Interview Mistakes

Poor Preparation Inadequate preparation results in generic questions and missed opportunities to evaluate specific candidate strengths and concerns.

Inconsistent Evaluation Without standardized questions and evaluation criteria, you cannot fairly compare candidates or make objective decisions.

Rushing the Process Compressed timelines prevent thorough evaluation and can result in poor hiring decisions that are expensive to correct.

Evaluation Errors

Overemphasis on Technical Skills While technical competency is important, communication skills, cultural fit, and professional attitude often determine long-term success.

Ignoring Red Flags Address concerning behaviors or responses directly rather than hoping they’ll improve after hiring.

Inconsistent Standards Maintain consistent evaluation criteria across all candidates to ensure fair comparison and optimal decision-making.

Section 8: Special Considerations for Remote Hiring

Remote Work Assessment

Remote positions require additional evaluation considerations beyond traditional role requirements:

Home Office and Technical Setup Assess their work environment, internet reliability, and technical capabilities. Poor setup can impact productivity and professional presentation.

Self-Management Abilities Evaluate their ability to work independently, manage time effectively, and maintain motivation without direct supervision.

Communication in Remote Settings Test their ability to communicate clearly in writing and participate effectively in video calls and virtual meetings.

Time Zone and Scheduling Considerations

Consider how different time zones impact collaboration and communication requirements. Evaluate:

Availability for required meeting times
Flexibility for urgent communications
Understanding of time zone coordination challenges

Building Remote Relationships

Assess their experience with remote work relationships and their approach to building professional connections virtually. This becomes particularly important for roles requiring significant collaboration.

Conclusion

The testing and interviewing phase represents your most important opportunity to evaluate candidates beyond their applications. Through carefully designed test tasks and structured interviews, you gather the evidence needed to make informed hiring decisions that benefit both your business and the candidate’s career.

Remember that this process is as much about helping candidates understand your opportunity as it is about evaluating their fit. Maintain professionalism, provide clear communication, and respect their time and effort throughout the process.

With solid test tasks, well-structured interviews, and systematic evaluation, you’ll be ready to move to the final stage: making your selection and extending an offer to the right candidate. Part 5 will guide you through the final decision-making process and help you successfully complete your hiring journey.

The investment in thorough testing and interviewing pays dividends through better hires, reduced turnover, and improved team performance. Take the time to do this phase properly, and you’ll set the foundation for a successful long-term working relationship.